About
Wagner Insurance Agency
We believe you deserve an insurance company that ensures you are properly covered at the most competitive rate and provides exceptional customer service.


We offer a range of policies for individuals, families, & businesses
Providing Coverage for Over 30 years
Doing business since 1992, Wagner Insurance Agency is an independent insurance agency specializing in Medicare, Life, Auto, Home, Business, and Farm Insurance. We work with dozens of insurance companies so we can offer our clients appropriate coverage for them. Our clients are located all across Ohio, giving us a great feel for the insurance landscape. We design plans with a proper benefit structure, which we combine with personalized insurance advice aimed at helping our clients make better-informed decisions.
Our Mission
Our mission is to provide seniors, individuals, businesses and farm owners with assistance in understanding and making the right insurance decisions. We have the skills, knowledge, and experience to help meet our client’s established goals. Our personal goal is to make sure our clients are insured properly, accurately, and strategically at the most competitive rate available.
Carriers We Represent
At Wagner Insurance Agency, we partner with several different insurance agencies in order to provide our clients with the solution that benefits them the most.
Life and Health Carriers:
Aetna
Allwell
Ameritas
Anthem
Banner Life
Dental Care Plus
The Health Plan
Humana
Lumico
Medical Mutual
Medigold
Molina
Mutual of Omaha
Protective Life
SilverScript
SureBridge
UnitedHealthcare
Wellcare

American Modern

American Reliable

American Strategic Insurance

Bristol West

BTIS

CHUBB

Foremost

Gateway Underwriters

Grange

Hagerty

Liberty Mutual

Markel

MetLife

Nationwide

Nationwide Farm

Pekin

Progressive

Safeco Insurance

Travelers
Contact Rick Wagner today!
Wagner Insurance Agency is an independent insurance agency specializing in Medicare, Life, Auto, Home, Business, Farm and Equine Insurance in Ohio.